Did someone forward this email to you? Sign up here to get the next edition.
Friends,
I’m sorry to be that person, but we’re 33 sleeps away from Christmas. Which means we’re 9 sleeps away from 1 December, when you’re legally allowed to put up decorations and play carols (I don’t make the rules).
And what also happens this time of year? That’s right, review season. And if your company is anything like the one’s I’m working with, it’s busy.
A resource I have found myself revisiting time and time again while navigating one of the most emotive times of year, is this report from Pave.
Sometimes you make pay decisions easily, and get internal buy in. Sometimes you just need to know what everyone else is doing, so you can break the deadlock. That’s what this report is.
It deep dives into the real stats on what people are planning to give as increases in 2027, as well as crucial insights on how companies are bonusing, tackling pay transparency, or the evergreen question of how to pay AI talent.
Consider it my gift guide (no I’m not doing one of those this year…)
Enjoy this week’s edition ✌️
LATEST EDITIONS
In case you’re new here (or just missed it) here’s the past three editions of the FNDN Series:
IN PARTNERSHIP WITH
3 HR automations worth stealing (and how to build them)
Everyone's talking about agentic HR. But what are People teams actually doing with it?
For its Agentic HR Playbook, Leapsome went straight to the people building it:
Zapier: a Slack helpdesk that answers routine HR questions and escalates sensitive ones.
Ethena: an AI assistant that pushes managers to give specific, useful feedback.
BEAT81: automated onboarding for 15+ new starters a week, saving 10+ hours a month.
Three real examples, broken down step by step, so you can try them yourself.
You don't need to be an AI expert. Just pick one and give it a go.
Leapsome is the Agentic HR Platform. For lean people teams with outsized business impact.
Thank you for supporting our sponsors, who keep this publication free.
Know a startup Head of People looking for answers 🙋 why not forward this to them for some instant karma? ✨
FROM TODAY’S INTERVIEW
Stop hiring people that are just "ok" (How to build the bar, then raise it)
This edition is based on a recent episode of the FNDN Series podcast, with Manifest’s CPO, Harry Uffindell.
Harry Uffindell is Chief People Officer at Manifest OS, which powers AI-native law firms and recently raised a $60M Series A from Menlo Ventures and Kleiner Perkins. He was previously part of the founding team at Partly and Chief People Officer at Partly. There he helped scale the team from 5 to about 200 people globally and raise roughly $100M, including a Series B led by DST Global. Earlier, he led BizOps & Strategy at Airbnb in Sydney, after its acquisition of Tilt, where he was the first APAC employee. He is also an active angel investor with 40+ investments and a syndicate lead, backing Pre-Seed and Seed founders across industries. He is based in New York and has 3 young boys.
Partly did 50 interviews before hiring a junior designer.
Most teams would have stopped much earlier and settled for an "ok" candidate.
When they finally started, the hiring manager's reaction was proof it was worth it: "Thank God we waited."
That story comes from Harry Uffindell, now Chief People Officer at Manifest. Before that, he spent five and a half years on the founding team at Partly, the New Zealand auto-parts tech company that raised its Series B at a US$500 million valuation this year. He helped grow it from five people to around 200.
Fifty is an extreme case, and Harry is clear most roles call for balance. But his view is that an empty seat is still cheaper than an "ok" person in it. You spend weeks interviewing, the hire struggles through probation, and three months later you're "spinning [your] wheels and doing it again".
So he built a hiring process that catches "ok" at every stage, from building the bench, through to the 45-day check they run.
Build your bench before the role exists
The best people are rarely on the market, so at Partly, hiring often started years before a role even opened.
Every new joiner was asked on day one who the best two or three people they'd ever worked with were, and interviews ended with a similar question: if someone you've worked with started a company tomorrow, who would you follow?
Those names went on a list, and the team kept in touch (event invites and the occasional personal note) until the timing was right. One engineering lead joined Partly four years after first choosing a competitor.
At the junior end, Partly partnered with top university student societies and hired the two or three go-to people in each year group. The next year group followed them in, and it "almost became like this flywheel effect".
Define the role before the job ad goes live
When a team is scaling fast, every empty seat hurts, so the instinct is to get the job ad up and start interviewing.
Harry learnt the hard way that speed up front "can elongate the process in the end".
His fix is a role launch: 30 to 45 minutes with the hiring manager and recruiter before anything goes live. Together they agree on:
the one thing this person will own (what they'd say if someone asked them in the hallway),
the problem they're solving, and how it's being solved today,
what success looks like at 30 and 90 days, and at six to 12 months,
the skills and values where they need to be spiky, and how each will be tested, and
who sits on the interview panel, plus the level and comp.
Busy hiring managers don't want another doc to fill in, so Harry built a Claude skill that interviews them on the drive home and hands the recruiter a v0.1. (A voice note and any AI assistant gets you most of the way.)
Once the role is clear, move fast. It's a startup's edge over big companies that can take five weeks to decide.
Interview for care and ownership
Harry's filter for great people is what he calls "self-guided missiles". Point them at an ambiguous problem and they'll go after it, pulling in resources and owning it end to end.
To find them, he looks for care first. "So many things are downstream from level of care," he said, whether that's obsession with the craft, the problem or the mission.
Then he digs:
What role did you play in moving that metric?
Was the problem handed to you, or did you go after it?
Why did you approach it that way, and what were the trade-offs?
Someone who was one of 60 people watching the work happen runs out of answers quickly.
Give a bar raiser the final say
The bar raiser is borrowed from Amazon. At Partly, it was someone outside the hiring manager's team who could veto any hire. The hiring manager is under pressure to fill a seat, but the bar raiser's only job is to protect talent density.
The final stage was three values interviews, each scoring two or three values out of four and asking whether this person raises or lowers the bar for their level. Then came the post-loop debrief.
Everyone starts with a silent read of the interview notes.
The bar raiser ignores the positives and drills into the concerns, like a two out of four on a core value.
The panel is asked for counter-evidence, then weighs how much each amber flag matters for the role.
For some roles, there's a final call with the CEO.
Every debrief ended with one question: what are we excited about? Harry calls it "more art than science", and it only comes after the scores. But if nobody wanted to run out of the room and tell the team, they'd probably have settled for "ok".
That's why an all-threes scorecard worried him more than a mixed one. "I'd almost rather see a bunch of fours and a bunch of twos."
He admits the bar raiser "causes a lot of frustration" for teams with their backs against the wall, but he rates it among the most impactful things Partly did. Everyone who joins knows they cleared a high bar, and so does everyone they work with.
Check the bar after they start
In Harry's experience, exceptional people show it early, often within three weeks and sometimes within three days.
So the process doesn't end at the offer. At 45 days, everyone who interviewed the new hire is asked whether they'd keep their score, raise it or lower it.
If the scores drop, look inward first. Was the role brief clear, was the interview rigorous, and was success defined early enough? Those answers feed straight back into the next role launch.
Holding the bar at every stage
If you can only adopt one stage this quarter, start with the role launch. It's 45 minutes, and every other stage gets easier once it's done.
Here's a question for you: think about your last hire. When the offer went out, was the room excited, or just relieved?
Hit reply and tell me which stage of your hiring process is most likely to let the bar slip.
Where to find Harry
LinkedIn: follow Harry here.
Company: check out Manifest OS.

If you enjoyed this post or know someone who may find it useful, please share it with them and encourage them to subscribe.
SMALL BITES
A roundup of the most interesting stuff from the week:
[Career ReLAUNCH] Engagement hit a 15-year low: add one "what's expected?" question
[Kelly Balthrop] Should your layoff memo cite AI? What 8 recent cuts show
[Barbara Matthews] Remote has vibe coded it's entire HR tech stack
That’s all from me this week.
Sure, this is technically the end of the newsletter, but we don’t have to end here! I’d love this to be a two-way chat, so let me know what you found helpful, any successes you’re seeing, or any questions you have about startup compensation.
Until next week,

When you’re ready, here’s three ways I can help you:
1. Tools & resources
Resources and tools that give you what you need to build your own startup compensation practices.
2. Comp consulting
Building startup compensation practices that are clear, fair and competitive.
3. Startup People Summit
A 1-day annual event for People professionals in scaling companies. Creating the playbook for startup people practices. Grab recordings from past events, or subscribe to join the next summit.







