Friends,

I’m taking a little break and enjoying a moment of reflection after one the biggest things I’ve ever done.

If you were at Startup People Summit, thank you.

If you weren’t — I hope you’ll join us next year (it’s 100% coming back).

It was a massive high. And now I’m taking some time to celebrate.

See you next week.

Matt

Know a Head of People handling startup compensation 🙋 why not forward this to them for some instant karma?

Did someone forward this to you? Make sure to hit subscribe and save them the click next time!

The Gender Pay Gap Isn’t What You Think It Is

with Math Nerd and Empath Aubrey Blanche-Sarellano

Aubrey Blanche Serano is the founder of MathPath and former VP at Culture Amp, where she led an industry‑leading effort to build pay equity and earned recognition for achieving one of the smallest gender pay gaps among peer tech firms.

With expertise at the intersection of people, ethics and responsible AI, Aubrey operationalises equity into business systems — transforming abstract values into measurable outcomes. Aubrey’s blunt, data‑driven approach underpinned Culture Amp’s claim: “We fucking won pay transparency.”

Here’s what we covered:

  • Why the gender pay gap and pay equity are not the same

  • How auditing twice a year built real insight (and accountabilit)

  • When you should and shouldn’t accept counteroffers

  • How L&D investment can close pay gaps indirectly

  • How to align comp philosophy with values and talent retention

  • Why transparency about pay decisions matters to Gen Z and millennials

  • What realistic thresholds like 5% tell us about progress

My 5 Key Takeaways:

Pay‑gap ≠ pay‑equity

The gender pay gap is a broad, aggregate figure — it shows the average pay difference across genders, not like‑for‑like pay differences. Aubrey emphasises companies typically misunderstand it as reflecting role‑by‑role inequity, when it often originates from structural imbalance in role distribution.

Audit, then audit again

Culture Amp conducted pay‑equity audits twice per year. That cadence matters—auditing only annually or on hire skews results, because organisational change shifts numbers quickly. Aubrey says: “You should never assume you’ve achieved it without checking your work.”

No out‑of‑cycle adjustments

Though counteroffers are tempting for retention, Culture Amp stopped making them outside review cycles — even when competitive. Data showed counteroffers had high attrition risk long term. Prioritising pay equity — even at the cost of losing short‑term candidates — proved more effective for retention and cultural consistency.

Develop to retain — and close pay gaps

Retention and pay equity intersect. At Culture Amp, female engineers were disproportionately leaving, which skewed the pay gap. So leadership invested in L&D dollars specifically to retain high‑performing women. That alone shaved the gender pay gap by half a percentage point — without touching base pay.

Values matter to modern talent

Millennials and Gen Z care deeply about values alignment. Aubrey explains that younger hires expect organisations to justify not just the pay level, but the philosophy behind it. Transparency about how compensation is determined helps attract and retain people who value fairness over highest dollar.

Comp philosophy is your retention tool

Rather than competing in salary auctions, Aubrey pushed for “good enough, fair enough” compensation. Culture Amp positioned itself to attract people who value clarity and equity — reducing churn among those who cared more about fairness than the top offer.

Communication as recruitment lever

Training recruiters to explain compensation philosophy (like why the offer is X, or how decisions were made) mattered. Many candidates responded positively when compensation was unpacked, not just compared, and this alignment kept Culture Amp competitive even with tighter budgets.

5% is a benchmark, not shame

In Australia, the Workplace Gender Equality Agency defines “no pay gap” within ±5%. Aubrey emphasises that getting within that band is exceptional — and that declaring your current status transparently builds trust and momentum toward equity.

Where to Find Aubrey

Listen, watch or read the full interview here.

Got a specific topic you want me to cover or a guest you’d love to nominate? Hit reply to this email and let me know.

How was this edition?

Login or Subscribe to participate

Here’s three things that may also be of interest to you:

  1. FNDN: Helping startups build compensation practices that are clear, fair and competitive. We can build your compensation philosophy, job level framework and compensation bands. Speak to us here.

  2. Compensation Tools and Resources: Resources and tools for giving you what you need to build your own startup compensation practices.

  3. Startup People Summit: A 1-day, virtual event & community giving you everything you need to build and scale your people practices. 31 July - 9am-4pm AEST.

Reply

or to participate

Keep Reading

No posts found