Transcript 0:00 [on-hold music] Welcome to the Foundation Series, your deep dive into startup compensation with industry leaders from across the startup world. 0:13 Join me, Matt McFarlane, a people operations leader turned compensation specialist, as we uncover the strategies and practices driving success in tech startups around the world. 0:22 Get insights from heads of people, founders, and experts as we explore how to build robust compensation frameworks that not only fuel growth and retention, but do so in the dynamic startup environment that we all know and love. 0:34 Let's get into it. [on-hold music] All right, so in today's episode, it's all about talking about getting your first compensation cycle right as a startup. 0:52 So I know in our previous episode, we talked about it's never too early to get your compensation philosophy in place or your first compensation philosophy. You know, what's, what's your mentality? 1:03 What's your thought process when it comes to the first compensation cycle? Similar? Different? How do you, how do you sort of tackle it from a, you know, an early stage head of people position? Yeah. 1:13 Well, look, I do not envy anyone in that position. It's really hard. You're gonna need help. You're gonna need a support structure. So, [chuckles] uh, you know, find your, find your support team quickly and lean on them. 1:25 Um, but yeah, I think, uh, lots of things to, to bear in mind, uh, the most important being, again, uh, start early and keep it simple for now and, um, uh, yeah, and document everything. 1:39 But we can go through like a little bit of a roadmap of, you know, what to, what to bear in mind and when, and take it from there. Yeah. I think that's a great approach. 1:48 Talk me through what you think are some of the, like, the key steps, the key milestones when it comes to thinking through what that first compensation philosophy or rather the compensation cycle can look like. Yeah. 1:59 Okay. Well, let's assume you've got the comp philosophy, um, you know, agreed, signed off by everyone. Everybody loves it. Um, but y- you know, it's there, it's been documented, everyone's on board. 2:10 So now we're talking about, you know, really, um, sort of nailing the comp cycle and getting it, um, from, uh, yeah, from start to finish. 2:18 So where, uh, the start is, you know, assessing where people are right now, and the finish is, um, you know, 2:26 folks get paid their new compensation, um, at the end of, you know, whichever, uh, whichever month this project finishes. [chuckles] Um, cool. 2:37 So to start, uh, you know, for sure you need to make sure that the, the scaffolding that we mentioned earlier, so that people's, um, HR data is correct, in the correct system, um, you know, cleaned and, you know, all reads in the same way. 2:54 You've accounted for currency changes. Uh, you know, make sure that you've cleaned the data and it's all, um, you know, it's all in one spot. It's all understandable. 3:04 If you pulled a report, anybody would be able to, um, immediately see like for like and understand, you know, what you're comparing with who-- w- with what. 3:13 So you should have, um, obviously like, uh, you know, departments, teams within departments, hopefully employee levels within their team framework. Um, 3:27 uh, and yeah, have that all, have it all sort of, uh, in one spot ready, uh, re- ready to go. 3:34 Um, assuming that's all in a good spot, uh, and assuming that folks ha-- so employees have been correctly mapped to their level and there's, um, you know, there's an understanding amongst managers and a calibration that's happened that, um, means that a, you know, a P three software engineer is, um, 3:56 you know, comparable to a P three, uh, marketing person or w- whatever that might be, um, then you're already in a, you know, i- i- in a, in a great spot. 4:08 Um, now, assuming you have, uh, a good data source, uh, hopefully, uh, the data source will be able to tell you, um, you know, 4:19 what, um, well, what you should be paying all these folks in their different job families and if-- in their different levels. 4:27 Um, and hopefully for each role, uh, well, for each, for each role and for each level within the role, you'll have identified the, um, the salary range that you'd like to, that you'd like to offer. 4:39 So if your midpoint is say, uh, target midpoint is say the sixtieth, and you'll allow a, um, you'll allow a plus minus, I don't know, fifteen, fifteen percent, uh, from the midpoint either way. 4:54 So that will hopefully have been crystallizing your comp philosophy, but you should be able to have that, um, sort of really clearly, uh, you know, really clearly outlined. 5:04 Um, depending on what the philosophy is, so let's assume, um, you know, you've decided to go for a pay for performance, um, uh, ph- philosophy, then it might be the case that you have a merit matrix. 5:19 So, um, depending on how folks have scored in their, in their performance reviews, it might be, um, that a, I don't know, someone who's greatly exceeding expectations, uh, will get a blanket, I don't know, ten percent increaseOr it may be that depending on where they sit in the salary range, so if they are, um, so below the midpoint but are greatly exceeding, then they actually get a bump to take them higher than the 10%, than the 10% where you exceed. 5:53 Oh, gotcha. So, a say 15%. So kind of coming up with a set of rules for, like, a few different criteria that you might see in your data set. Exactly. 6:00 So it might be the case that you wanna go off, um, off of the current comp ratios. 6:06 So, uh, if someone is low within the band but is performing really well, then they will get an increased multiplier to move them quickly up the band. 6:16 Um, conversely, if a, uh, you know, someone who's already really high in the band, um, is also, uh, greatly exceeding, then it might be the case that they get a little bit of a smaller increase so that they don't sort of move out of the band, um, you know, at [chuckles] breakneck speed. 6:33 Now, that might not work with your comp philosophy. You might be like, "Hey, actually, I don't want there to be an upper limit on my ba- on my band. I'm totally okay with breaking the band." 6:41 You know, that's totally fine as long as it's in your comp philosophy. Um- [laughs] Yeah. No, it's funny you say that. Like, that was such a novel concept to me until, like, last year, I wanna say. 6:51 Which just seems crazy, but it's... it also I think just talks to, like, you know, compensation's been around forever. 6:57 But there's still, [chuckles] there's still so many different things that you can learn about ways that are doing it right for your business, right? Like, and again, that's what it comes back to. But, um, yeah, I agree. 7:06 You know, you don't always have to, you don't always have to, like, recognize the upper limit if it's actually gonna constrain, again, you know, finding or keeping the best people. Absolutely. 7:16 And, you know, it's so counterintuitive to, to feel that, hey, our best performer who, you know, nailed the interview, and we brought them, uh, we brought them in at the upper range of the band, uh, at the upper range of the band. 7:29 Well, they're still performing like a superstar, but we're gonna sort of cut their wings off because there's no business need for a promotion, and they're already at the top of the band, so they're not gonna get anything. 7:39 How demotivating. I would hate that. Like, as a, you know, as an employee, I would be so offended by that. Um- Yeah... so, you know. 7:46 And it kind of forces your people back toward the median from a performance perspective as well, right? 7:51 Like, if you think about it, you've got this person who's kicking goals, and then suddenly you're saying, "Well, we're not going to reward you." Like, are they going to stop trying so hard, right? 7:58 Because you're not incentivizing it. I mean, I think so. Um, it does... I, I do see organizations where, um, you know, their values and their ethos may be more, uh, not socialist, but maybe more- [laughs] Egalitarian. 8:12 [laughs] Yeah, egalitarian. And that, you know, that's totally fine if it's the ethos of the, um, uh, of the organization. 8:20 Personally, though, as a, you know, as an HR director, um, I need to be able to stand by the comp philosophy and really believe in it and really believe I'm doing the best for my people. 8:30 So it needs to be something that aligns with my values. 8:33 And, um, yeah, in, in, in our case, I would really struggle with, um, uh, you know, putting a hard stop at, uh, at an, at an upper range and then not, um, yeah, not rewarding our best performers. 8:46 I think for those ones as well, like, there's such, there's such a range of ways you can try and deal with it, like whether or not you do close the gap a little bit with them from a base salary perspective, and then maybe the remainder is a lump sum. 8:56 Like, there's lots of different ways that you can be creative around trying to make sure that you're sticking within the sort of intent of your compensation philosophy, but not, like, limiting, yeah, the pay-per-performance philosophy element. 9:08 Yeah. Yeah. Couldn't agree more. Uh, another thing that we've been seeing a lot more of, uh, at Ravio is, uh, people... So, uh, HR teams also playing a lot with, um, offering non-monetary rewards. 9:22 So it might be that, you know, as you say, you go with a, you know, spot bonus to reward performance or a big equity grant, something like that, but also things like sabbaticals have been coming up a lot more. 9:32 Um, you know, paid sabbatical, two weeks, a month. Fantastic. What a... You know, I would love that. [laughs] 100... I was gonna say, arguably worth more than the money it costs the company as well. Oh, totally. 9:43 Like, I mean, you only have to look at one or two studies to realize how valuable this is becoming more and more to people. 9:50 I think, you know, A, we're in a burnout epidemic in, in many ways ever since COVID, but also we're seeing a larger introduction of a, a younger sort of generation of the workforce where that sort of stuff is incredibly valuable to them. 10:02 So yeah, I, I have also seen them used really well. I can't say I've seen them increased a lot. That's just my experience. 10:10 But yeah, I c- I can see how they'd be incredibly valuable, uh, rather than just going straight for, for cash. Yeah. 10:15 And it might be the case that, uh, you know, is there a scenario whereby it's worth saying, uh, you know, putting it to the person involved and saying, "Hey, here's what we're th- here are the options that we're thinking. 10:26 [laughs] You know, what works best for you? Like, we're open for, we're open to all of these options of rewarding. 10:32 Um, you know, would you rather the cash in your pocket, or would you rather the, you know, the sabbatical?" Whatever it might be. I think I, I, I think that's great to have the, uh, yeah, the option to choose. 10:42 Not to mention the goodwill I think it builds when you can tailor something to the individual. I mean, it, it obviously... 10:48 you know, it starts to introduce complexity when it comes to tracking and consistency and fairness, but it's, it's also never been easier really with a lot of the tooling that you can get, um, to be able to do something like that. 10:59 But I think the impact it can have to say to someone, "Hey, you've done... You've had an incredible year. You know, which of these many options would you potentially consider?" 11:08 And to be able to have that choice would be amazing. Um, I couldn't, could only imagine, you know, how I would've received something like that if I was an employee. Yeah. Yeah. Totally agree. [laughs] All right. 11:21 Nice one. So we've kinda talked about, like, you know, what's a good, like, minimum vi- viable product from a, a cycle design perspective. 11:29 What do you think are some of the things people need to look for out the other side of it when they're going, "Okay, you know, deep breath out, exhalation, done it, congratulations, pats on the back." 11:38 It's probably arguably one of the hardest times of the year.What are some of the things that you think are worth looking at as, uh, okay, let's do a little bit of a retro. What are the things that worked well? 11:47 What didn't work well? Um, or maybe we should be looking ahead to, uh, to, to next year's cycle. Yeah, totally. 11:54 So I think, um, one thing that's helped me a lot in the past is doing a little bit of a focus group for the, for the retro of the, the customers, our, our employees. 12:04 So getting folks from different teams, different levels, uh, to do, uh, yeah, a little bit of a, a focus retro group. And it's really interesting to me to, uh, get their sense of, 12:18 tell me what our comp philosophy is, you know? [laughs] How well can you explain it to me? Um, so I think that's a great indication to see, you know, has the message landed? 12:29 Has the internal, internal PR machine worked appropriately? Have I managed my... 12:35 You know, have I-- To what extent have we enabled our line managers to really educate their teams on, um, what the comp philosophy is and how it works in relation to them in this particular comp cycle? 12:48 And there's no way you can figure that out adequately without asking folks, um, what, you know, what their own experience has been. And, you know, th- I mean, this is a reflection of my performance, I'm sure. 13:00 Uh, I, I recognize that. But time and time again, um, you know, I've had someone in the focus group say, "Oh, I, I, I never heard about this." And I'm like, "Oh my God." 13:11 [laughs] You know, there I was thinking that everybody's bored of having me and, and other leaders sort of talk about the comp philosophy, and this person can't remember it, right? So- Well, don't... I think-... 13:21 I've not done a good enough job. [laughs]... you were-- I'm just saying that, I've definitely felt that. 13:24 I've, I've heard or read somewhere, and maybe it's totally made up, but it's like apparently you have to say something eight times, I think, before it's like, actually, you know, one person hears it themselves once. 13:35 But I love in particular your point around asking them to kind of recite it back to you, because how... 13:41 I don't know if, if this has been your experience as well, but I-I certainly had a lot of compensation, um, you know, retro surveys or something like that. 13:48 We've a- we've asked questions like, um, you know, how fair do you think your pay is? And I think it was only after doing it a couple times where I was like, what does that even mean? 13:56 Like, do, do people even know what fair is? 13:59 And I think even understanding what the compensation philosophy is, that has to have happened first and foremost in my mind before someone can say whether or not it's, it's fair, because you have to sort of define fair through that process. 14:11 But yeah, it- Yeah... why, why ask people whether or not they think it was a good, bad, or indifferent process if they never potentially understood how the process, you know, was supposed to work from the get-go? 14:22 That's a great little litmus test. I, I'd add that I, I think when assessing fairness, people tend to think about what they're... 14:32 Not-- They don't tend to think about what they're paid in absolute terms, but they think about it in relative terms to other, um, uh, other colleagues. 14:41 So I think also concluding the comp review and, you know, whatever letter you send, uh, formalizing the, the change, um, you know, if you can, uh, visualize, uh, to the employee, you know, where they started and where they're at, like over time, uh, but also where they sit in relation to other folks. 15:02 I mean, it depends how big the organization is. [laughs] You know, if there's two people in your team, you can't really do that. Um, but, uh, it can be a really good... 15:11 Uh, you know, if your comp philosophy is stro- is strong, and if you have conviction in your pay equity, that's a really strong card to play. The organization needs to be big enough, though. [laughs] Yeah. 15:21 And, and of the right maturity. But, um- Yeah... no, I, I love the idea of that. I think it's such a... Yeah, it's, it's a clever play. 15:28 And you're right, like, you know, at the end of the day, people are all gonna speak to each other anyway, so I think being able to be as upfront as you can to the extent that you can is only going to, to play to your benefit. 15:38 But, um, amazing. Well, this has been... It's been short, but it's been incredibly, um, beneficial. Thank you so much for, for running through this. 15:45 So I guess for me, some of the, the, the big takeaways, which the first one I couldn't more agree with, get your data right, get it clean, get that scaffolding in place. 15:54 Um, you know, when it comes to running that compensation cycle, build some of these basic rules around how you're going to treat people when it comes to, to certain pay outcomes. 16:02 I love this idea of asking your people at the end of the process to recount the compensation philosophy to you and work out whether or not your PR efforts had actually been successful. 16:12 And then last, but definitely an incredible one, is help people understand how their pay compares to others if possible, but at the very least, kind of where they came from and where they went to. 16:22 Those are some amazing takeaways. Thank you so much for joining us. Thanks for having me, Matt. It's been great. Thanks for joining us on another edition of the Foundation Series. 16:31 [upbeat music] Make sure to head over to our website to subscribe to the Foundation Series for monthly editions featuring future interviews on startup compensation. 16:39 In each edition, we'll explore the different strategies, trends, and challenges faced by startups around the world. 16:45 If you have a burning topic you'd like me to cover or a standout guest that you wanna hear from, drop me an email so I can dive deeper into the compensation topics that matter most to you. 16:55 Join me next time as we continue to uncover the strategies and practices driving success in global tech startups around the world. Thanks for listening. 17:02 [upbeat music]