Transcript 0:00 [on-hold music] Welcome to the Foundation series, your deep dive into startup compensation with industry leaders from across the startup world. 0:13 Join me, Matt McFarlane, a people operations leader turned compensation specialist, as we uncover the strategies and practices driving success in tech startups around the world. 0:22 Hear insights from heads of people, founders, and experts as we explore how to build robust compensation frameworks that not only fuel growth and retention, but do so in the dynamic startup environment that we all know and love. 0:34 Let's get into it. [on-hold music] In today's episode, we're exploring how in fast-growth startups, your comp practices will break. It's not if, but when. 0:52 We explore the early warning signs and how to rebuild compensation structures that grow with you, not against you. 0:57 Before we dive straight into the topics, I'd love you to spend a brief moment, and for those who aren't familiar with you, a little bit about who you are and, and what you do. I love that. 1:05 The, the, the not being familiar with me, it's like they'd be perfectly forgiven for not being familiar with me. [laughs] Uh, so my name is Naomi Trickey. I'm the chief people officer at, at a company called Muse. 1:16 Um, we provide hospitality software, uh, for hotels in order to free up the people who work in those hotels to provide remarkable experiences for their guests. 1:26 I'm also a ned, uh, for, uh, an embedded finance company called Griffin. Um, so I chair the people and governance committee. Um, so that is me. 1:36 I've worked in technology for a scarily long time, uh, in a variety of roles. Um, and but started becoming a chief... I became a chief people officer, uh, about ten years ago. Um, so I've been doing this work since then. 1:48 All right, Naomi. In today's section, we're gonna talk about when does compensation break. So, you know, Muse and other organizations that you're a part of or have been a part of, they go through various stages. 2:00 I know I have seen my fair share of, uh, you know, not just comp, but many things breaking and, and having to be, uh, you know, fixed and rebuilt along the way. 2:08 Maybe let's start with a little bit of context first before we sort of- Mm-hmm... dive into the various different stages of Muse. 2:13 But tell me, when you joined the organization, how big was it, uh, then and how big is it now? 2:19 When I joined, it was about sort of between five hundred and six hundred people, so it was about two and a half years ago, um, because they'd done the classic COVID thing of growing and then retrenching and then growing again. 2:30 Um, and then we hired five hundred people in my first year, f- about five hundred people in my second year, um, and then we've seen average attrition, so we're about thirteen hundred now. 2:41 Um, and then valuation, we achieved unicorn status, so north of a billion dollars in valuation. Wow. And that's where we're at. And then we operate- Yeah... in, um, we've got about forty different nationalities. Amazing. 2:55 And, and like, as in people employed in different countries as well, or just that's your demographic makeup? The demographic, but then we, we are remote first. Um- Yeah... 3:03 so we do have people, I don't even know in how many countries our people are operating- [laughs] Too many to count. [laughs]... because they tend to move around. 3:09 But we have, um, we have about eighteen different entities, starting point. Yeah. Wow. Okay. That's amazing. 3:17 And, and if you were to think of like, I mean, you gave some incredible, you know, circumstances in which you would understand something like comp, but I'm sure many other parts of the people function tend to heave and ho and potentially even break. 3:30 Yeah. What oc- what kind of surface in your mind is some of the key stages there? 3:35 And maybe not even just with Muse, but with other organizations where you go, "You know, this for me is a clear sort of tipping point at which we need to consider something like comp." Yeah. I mean, I read... 3:47 I like, like everybody else, I read LinkedIn, you know, uh, for ideas and, and, and I read my peers' thoughts on, on the work and, um, I'm always sort of slightly envious of people who say, "I'm at a company of a hundred and fifty people, and we've started to put in place comp structures," and I'm like, "Oh my God, you're so smart," um, because, [clears throat] 4:10 it's, you know... I would love for it to be at that stage in some ways and, and, and for that forethought to have been applied. 4:17 But hindsight is twenty-twenty, blah, blah, blah, and, um, and the reality is that often these organizations, the kind of organizations I work for, so fast growth SaaS companies essentially, um, they grow organically, and actually that's part of the joy. 4:33 You know, there's a kind of level of experimentation and seeing what works and so on. 4:38 What is interesting to me, most interesting to me, and the stage I'm really fascinated by at this point in my career, is that sort of pivot point when you're moving from that kind of hacky, sort of let's just do it stage, to, okay, now let's look at the friction point between growth and structures and let's figure out what are the new structures we, we need, um, and, and what are the, the, what old structures are no longer fit for purpose. 5:07 And so, for example, um, when I joined Muse, we didn't have an org-wide process for performance or pay. 5:17 So a couple of the teams had very granular, um, processes because the leaders within those organizations had put them in place, and they were perfect for that stage. 5:31 Um, and, and, and, and they were sort of almost works of art, these, these, these processes. They were really thoughtful and really helpful. 5:39 But I am accountable for, um, the entire organization, and there needs to be a process a- across, that works across the organization, and there needs... 5:50 Because, uh, not only because you need to report on it, but also you need, um, to have comparability in order to understand what's working in one place and what's not working in another. Um, and I can't... I... 6:03 It's not acceptable for me to say, "I don't have the data on that."Because they don't follow the same price slate. It's just not acceptable. 6:10 Um, the other critical point is a lot of these organizations depend heavily on internal mobility. Um, you can't have internal mobility... 6:18 I- internal mobility is compromised if different parts of the organization are operating in different ways. Um, and so you need that consistency. 6:27 Um, another thing that often happens is pay and performance conversations happen at the same time. Um, and, um, now obviously we don't work for free. 6:39 There is a relationship between performance and pay, but we all know what happens if you go into a conversation where you're expecting to hear about your pay, that is all you hear, um, and you miss that rich feedback that you should be expecting from your performance review. 6:55 So separating out those conversations. 6:58 Another classic, everything is done on a spreadsheet, and the endless points of failure that creates, and we're not over that, by the way, just for full transparency, I don't want people to walk away thinking that I'm saying that Muse is perfect because we are definitely not. 7:14 We are going through this with everyone else, but trying to reduce the points of failure, introduce guardrails and reduce the points of failure in the process. Another thing that happens, I've got a long list. 7:27 We had salary bands that were very granular. Um, and, and in other areas we had no salary bands at all. 7:34 And the interesting knotty problem there is on one hand, employees often really like that because they can see clear progression, uh, 'cause they get like a 3% increase and a... 7:45 you know, and it feels like they're going somewhere. But actually it drives the wrong conversations. It's drives very short-term behavior around pay and performance. And I-- my 7:59 interest and my desire is to drive a much more, much less transactional thinking around pay and performance. And for that, you have to be looking longer term. 8:09 And so the salary bands and the job gradings have needed to be adjusted and that, that work, that work is underway. Um, it is really, uh, as you know, I have a new director of total reward and her... 8:23 one of her Q2 projects actually is around, uh, job, job grades because they've also grown organically. 8:29 So what you, you, again, inconsistent, incomparable, and it, it, ultimately, the employee's left kind of going, "Well, the only way I can progress is by getting a pay rise." And it's just, it's just not true. Mm. Yeah. 8:42 That's, um, I guess that's a great, um, sign of a sort of a breaking point as well, is that if, if people are feeling that they have to do that, um, or if you are seeing that, you know, that attrition is driven by that, um, is that maybe your, your promotion processes are a little bit too arduous or your, your comp increase, uh, you know, processes. 8:58 I mean, there's certainly been stories that I've heard of where people have left the organization, come back at a higher level, and that was an easier door to go through than internally, um, in terms of, uh, being able to progress. 9:11 Yeah. So yeah. There's, there's a lot of different things there that are, are interesting little stress tests, aren't there? Yeah. And I've definitely... I haven't seen that at Muse actually. Our attrition is really low. 9:19 Um, but I have, I have seen it in other organizations and once, once that door is open and people are walking out of it, it's really, really, really hard to close it again, um, because it's an erosion of trust and e- essentially the, the... 9:36 one of the main roles, one of the main purposes of these structures and frameworks 9:41 is to establish trust because they give clarity, and nothing drives trust more than clarity, um, because people just understand where they s- where they stand. 9:53 Um, and, and then they can make a decision like the adults that they are about that. And we all know that when you go to another organization, that's when you get the big pay jumps, and organizations 10:06 like mine, you know, m- working at me is one of the wonderful things, many wonderful things about it, but one of the wonderful things about it is that, um, our growth rate means that we can often match the ambition of the people that work here. 10:19 I've worked in places where they're growing much more slowly, and so the ambition, but ambitious people work in this context, right? That, that is a common thread of all the people I work with. 10:30 And if your organization isn't growing fast enough, then it outstrips the organ- the ambitio- the rate of growth of the organization, and so you're forced to leave in order to progress. 10:41 And that can be to do with pay, but it can also be to do with new roles and skills development and so on and so forth. Um- Yeah. Yeah... 10:49 at Muse, our growth rate is pretty pacey and, um, and so actually we've been able to contain that to a certain extent, but you can't rest on your laurels, you know? 10:57 You have to keep, um, pushing and driving, uh, in this area because it really matters to... development matters to people. Mm. Yeah, I completely agree. It tends to be a, a, a very small company challenge, right? 11:09 Is how do you keep people for a longer in their career when their ambition does outpace the, the growth- Yeah... of the organization. 11:14 So it's, yeah, it's, it's nice to be in a place where you're kind of able to handle that with, uh, you know- It's a joy... with relative, relative scope. Yeah. Yeah. It's a joy. It's a joy. 11:22 And there's always new things going on, and we're building out fintech practice and, you know- Mm... there's, so there's always something going on at Muse like that. That becomes- Yeah... a different problem. 11:31 [laughs] Yeah. 11:32 Well, so what, what are some of the other sort of, you know, ca- canary in the coal mine type things that you look for to give you an indication that comp maybe isn't working for the stage of the organization? 11:42 I think you've, you've given a great like level set around, you know, as a CPO, and I'm looking at this from a, you know, strategic, internal mobility, et cetera. These are the, these are the things I'm looking for. 11:51 Um, but when these things are in place, what do you kind of look at and go, "Yeah, everything's kind of cool. 11:57 It's humming along," or actually we're starting to see, you know, signs or, or signals that we need to, to reevaluate these, uh, these areas? 12:05 We constantly measure engagement of our peopleMm-hmm Um, and actually because we have such a transparent culture, I don't need to look too hard for the signs that something is broken. Yeah. 12:17 I tend to hear about it, and, um, I either hear about it through our engagement surveys- Mm-hmm... or I hear about it directly from managers, or I hear about it directly from individuals. 12:28 [laughs] Um, I'm pretty open and people contact me all the time about all sorts of things. Um, and so, and we also... 12:37 We have, um, we have a company all hands, which is a, is probably one of our most critical cultural assets. 12:44 Um, I don't know if I've talked to you about it before, but, um, it's called the Boosh, so it's short for amuse- Definitely not... okay. It's called... It's short for amuse-boosh, um, because we do like a pun. 12:56 Um, and it's, um, uh, it- it's run by different teams at different weeks. Um, it's very high. We set very high standard in terms of the presentation, so you don't just walk up at the Boosh. You prepare. 13:10 Um, and then, um, and it's different themes every week and so on, different departments or whatever. Um, and but at the end we have something called Hammer Time, which is as- [laughs] I love it... 13:21 gladiatorial as it sounds. When new- [laughs]... when new people start, they're like, "Seriously? This happens every week?" Um, and, um, there's like- Please tell me there's parachute pants involved as well, right? 13:31 [laughs] I wish sometimes there were parachute pants. Um, but essentially you, um, uh, anyone can ask a question of anyone, and so often questions are submitted in advance. 13:43 Sometimes questions are asked live and then we also run a Slido, and at the same time we have a Slack channel, which is all Boosh chat. And so whilst the meeting's going on, all Boosh chat's running along. 13:56 And so when you're running, um, a Boosh, it's like it's a level of intensity in terms of k- um, managing a meeting because you're, you're all... It's like, it's like being a DJ, right? 14:07 Like, you are literally all over the place. Um, but those questions in Hammer Time can get really spiky. Um, and 14:18 we have a sort of level of respect that we expect from people because obviously we want that trust and openness to be in place such that people feel able to ask the questions, but everyone has to respect that someone also has to answer that question. 14:30 And when it's answering that question about pay in front of 500 people or whoever, however many are attending that week, that's pretty intense. And so I use those sorts... 14:41 And we have other meetings like it, so we have a version of the Boosh with, um, managers once a month. Um, and I use those sorts of meetings as canaries, um- Yeah... to understand. It, it... 14:53 Although they're not really canaries, they're more like really big ostriches that are like stampeding. [laughs] Happening in front of the entire company. 15:01 Yeah, there's nothing canary like- It's not a canary at that stage. [laughs] There's nothing canary like about them. So yeah, it's, it's good. You hear about it basically. I don't, I don't know- Yeah... 15:10 if that answers your question. 15:11 No, uh- It's not very subtle, but- Well, it, it does because I think so often, like, you know, my, my, my typical sort of go-to response is that it's like it's in the reporting, but it's, you know, often that's after the fact, and it's like- Yeah, it's like it-... 15:21 before you can kind of do something. Yeah. And so- Yeah... 15:23 yeah, I mean, the fact that you can create an environment, um, where people do feel comfortable to raise that, and I'm assuming you're also one where it's like, you know, it's, it's safe to say we either don't have an answer or it's something we hadn't considered or something- Oh, sure... 15:35 like that where, you know- Yeah... 15:36 and I think that's another, that's another thing that I really try to help people recognize more often is that even though comp feels like one of those things that you just have to have nailed because it's so deeply important and personal and all those sorts of things, we are still all humans at the end of the day, and we're all just trying to do the best that we can. 15:54 And, you know, if you take this approach of this is how we deliver compensation, and we think we've got it right, but also we're also open to feedback, it just kind of really de-risks this whole like, yeah, place of, you know, having it perfect and, and having to feel like you have to be really defensive of it as well. 16:10 I think it's another thing that gets people, um- It does... offside, especially- It does... 16:14 when someone comes to them and says, "Oh, you know, hey, I've just seen this job ad for that," and they feel like they have to justify everything right now and kind of kill it, you know, kill it now, this question of whether or not I can get a pay increase. 16:24 And it's like, just hear 'em out, understand where they're coming from, um, talk to them about what avenues there are to increase pay if there are, you know, those avenues and, and kind of create a bit of dialogue around it rather than making them feel like they're being necessarily punished for, for bringing something that's important to you- I-... 16:39 or to them... I couldn't agree more. I remember when I started, my team felt a bit beleaguered, I think, because they were getting really, really hammered in Hammer Time, uh, ironically. [laughs] And I 16:53 very quickly realized that the way around this problem is through it, and you don't get through, um, that tension by pretending it doesn't exist. 17:06 Um, and so there's been quite a bit of coaching about showing up at meetings, um, and, and the way in which you show up, and if you show up... 17:16 And I don't mean to sound trout- trite or patronizing, but if you show up with a positive mental attitude, then people are generally much more open to that. "Oh, she's human." Mm. 17:27 You know, "She's not trying to, she's not trying to dupe me, and she's, she seems like she's a kind person who's trying to do-" Yeah... "a good job, and okay, I can work with that." 17:37 And so you will see me on Hammer Time, and I will always smile, for example. Like, it's a really- Yeah... simple thing. [laughs] But I've taken... 17:46 I've thought a lot about how to present myself in person 'cause I do a lot of speaking in front of groups of people about often very sensitive topics, and things like smiling, planting your feet on the ground, taking a breath, welcoming people into the room, um, these are really simple things that you can do that create that environment in which people feel able to share with you- Mm... 18:10 but also respect you because I'm not, like, you know, I'm not trying to hurt anyone.I'm really just trying to do my best, and my team are too. Um, and I think that that, 18:23 yeah, it does sound trite, the positive mental attitude, but it re-it really is a very powerful... It is, like, one of the most powerful tools you have, I think. It's not toxic positivity either. It's not like- Yeah... 18:33 "Oh, look over here, guys. Everything's fine." No. Because it's not. But I think it's like, you know, like assuming positive intent, for example- Yeah... 18:38 is a really simple way of just going, "Actually, I'm sure you have the best intention. It maybe didn't come out that way, but it's... Yeah. There, you know, there, there is a good intention here. 18:46 Let's understand it, and let's uncover it, and kinda- Yeah... you know, go from there." Yes. Mm. Exactly. Yes. I love it. All right. My last question around this topic, you've kinda touched on this a little bit already. 18:55 So you kinda said when you got into to Muser about, what, 500 people, I think you said, and maybe it wasn't as much structure as, uh, as you would've liked, and so all of that needed to come in. 19:04 How do you typically, and I guess with hindsight being 2020 always, how do you typically think about the different sizes and stages of companies and, and what they maybe need to have in place from either a comp team or a tooling? 19:15 How do you sort of see that typically evolving, um- Yeah... over the, the scale of a company? Yeah. Phew. I don't think there's a typical. [laughs] Mm-hmm. Um, and I think you have to, um... I think you have to 19:28 sort of exist within the company to learn its ways. Um, you know, um, and, and, and it comes over time. 19:35 And, and ideally, you have a really strong relationship with the CEO and the founder, uh, or maybe the same people, whatever, and, and the rest of the leadership team because this really... 19:45 the messaging does start from the top when it comes to this kind of thing. Um, at Muse, it's very much a work in progress. 19:52 I really, like I said earlier, I don't wanna give the impression that we have it all resolved and locked down. I think that'd be really disingenuous. 19:58 Um, you know, I think it's important that you put the team structure in place to support, um, because this is a lot of work. So I hired a director of total rewards. Um, she has a customer success background. 20:12 Um, I didn't realize that was a particularly smart move. I mean, I think she's great, obviously. But, 20:19 um, until I was talking in one of my CPO, um, you know, we have a bunch of WhatsApp groups, and we're talking, and it turns out a couple of other chief people officers have done exactly the same thing. 20:29 And, um, I was like, "Oh, well, that's really interesting." Uh, um, but this person has worked, um... I know you know her, so it, you know, worked at M- Mercer and at Oyster. 20:39 So it's a real sweet spot of being customer-facing, but also understanding the employee environment and understanding benefits in its broadest, um, its broadest sense. 20:49 And so that, getting that team, the, the, the leader of that team in place is, is a critical, um, is a critical phase. 20:57 Making sure that you have the, um, platforms and the data, and again, this is a big one for us right now because we're moving from Bamboo to Workday, and it's an uphill struggle. 21:10 [laughs] Um, um, so we also, to that point about the team, we've hired an analyst, um, so thinking about the data architecture and the data side, and there's so much data involved in pay. 21:22 Creating salary bands is the next one, um, because they are things that you can share, and increasingly, we are being pushed by, um, legislation on transparency. At Muse- Mm... 21:33 it's like pushing at an open door because we have a very transparent culture. But it's not as straightforward as just sharing because people need to be enabled. They need to be... 21:44 You know, managers need to be supported, um, before they, their Slack lights up with 4,000 questions that they can't answer, you know. So there's a lot, there's a lot around that. 21:53 Um, and then the other relationship that's really important to build is with your finance business partners, I think, um, because they provide deep support on org design and modeling for every function, uh, within the business. 22:07 And for me, defining a pay philosophy and an approach is really... It's an ongoing dialogue that you need to have with, with the business between teams at different levels across functions. 22:21 Um, and, uh, so the, the, the final piece of the puzzle and the final thing that you need to have in place really is that relationship, that- Mm... 22:30 with the rest of the leadership team so that you can determine what the pay philosophy is, especially if you're working across geographies because there's so many different sort of expectations there. 22:42 Um, but- Absolutely... you know, there's always tension between growth and structure, as I've said earlier. Mm. And we have constraints. Money is not an infinite resource. 22:52 You talk to some of the larger tech companies, and they give the impression that it's all fine, but basically, when you dig deeper, um, it's because they don't have financial constraints- Mm... 23:01 and the, the rest of us have. So shifting from flexibility to structure has really been a process for us. Uh, and it's a- Yeah... dynamic one, and it's gonna keep, it's gonna keep going. Yeah. Beautiful. 23:13 Laid out an incredible roadmap there for, uh, for anyone considering [laughs] their own compensation needs, no matter their size. I appreciate it. Thank you so much for sharing. No worries. And that's a wrap. 23:24 We explored how to spot the early signs that your compensation model is no longer fit for scale and how to rebuild it with clarity and intent. 23:31 Stay tuned for more strategies to build resilient, future-proofed compensation foundations. Thanks for joining us on another edition of the Foundation series. 23:40 [upbeat music] Make sure to head over to our website to subscribe to the Foundation series for monthly editions featuring future interviews on startup compensation. 23:48 In each edition, we'll explore the different strategies, trends, and challenges faced by startups around the world. 23:54 If you have a burning topic you'd like me to cover or a standout guest that you wanna hear from, drop me an email so I can dive deeper into the compensation topics that matter most to you. 24:03 Join me next time as we continue to uncover the strategies and practices driving success in global tech startups around the world. Thanks for listening. 24:16 [outro music]